Top Cheap Hotels in New Buffalo

Only Handpicked and Verified Accommodations for Your Stay in New Buffalo, United States
Check-in
06Feb2026Select date
Check-out
07Feb2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room
New Buffalo is home to beautiful beaches like Lions Park and Weko Beach, as well as exciting spots like Four Winds Casino and the New Buffalo Railroad Museum. For your stay, you'll find a variety of accommodations, from cozy inns to waterfront hotels, each offering stunning lake views and easy beach access. This website provides a carefully selected list of top-rated hotels, ensuring you find excellent options based on guest reviews and amenities. Remember to book early, especially during summer and holidays, and check transportation options like local shuttles to explore the area.
View map
1-8 out of 8
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
Map400 yd from City Centre700 yd from New Buffalo Parks Dept
FromUS$ 205 /nightSelect
Map1.3 mi from City Centre1.1 mi from Four Winds Casino
FromUS$ 84 /nightSelect
Map1.1 mi from City Centre1.1 mi from New Buffalo Parks Dept
FromUS$ 64 /nightSelect
Map1.3 mi from City Centre1.3 mi from Four Winds Casino
FromUS$ 161 /nightSelect
Map1.2 mi from City Centre1.2 mi from New Buffalo Parks Dept
FromUS$ 62 /nightSelect
Map1.2 mi from City Centre1.2 mi from New Buffalo Parks Dept
FromUS$ 75 /nightSelect
FromUS$ 120 /nightSelect
Map1.4 mi from City Centre1.1 mi from Four Winds Casino
FromUS$ 169 /nightSelect

New Buffalo hotel price guide

A world of accommodation options awaits, from budget-friendly stays to luxurious retreats, with prices suited to every traveler's dream vacation.

⬆️ The highest price
US$ 205
⬇️ The lowest price
US$ 62
💸 Average price for
3-star hotels
US$ 120

Top-rated hotels in New Buffalo

According to guest feedback from the past year

Cozy Comforts for Family Stays:
Baymont By Wyndham New Buffalo
Relaxing Retreats by the Shores:
New Buffalo Inn & Spa
Convenient Access to Attractions:
Quality Inn Near Interstate I94
Modern Amenities for Business Travelers:
Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, Mi By Ihg
Charming Accommodations with Local Flair:
The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo
Stylish Suites for Romantic Getaways:
Bliss Point Inn & Suites
Budget-Friendly Options for Explorers:
Fairfield Inn And Suites New Buffalo

FAQs about hotels in New Buffalo

Use these answers to help plan your perfect trip

Which hotels in New Buffalo are recommended for families?
The Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo is family-friendly, offering amenities like an indoor pool and free breakfast. The Baymont by Wyndham also has comfortable family rooms and is conveniently located near local attractions.
What hotels in New Buffalo offer unique views?
The Neighborhood Hotel Grand Beach offers scenic views of the nearby shoreline and is a popular choice. Additionally, the New Buffalo Inn & Spa provides lovely views and a relaxing atmosphere.
Which hotels are best for couples in New Buffalo?
Bliss Point Inn & Suites and The Neighborhood Hotel New Buffalo are both excellent for couples, providing a romantic setting and amenities like cozy rooms and proximity to the beach.
What hotels are closest to New Buffalo's popular landmarks?
Quality Inn Near Interstate I94 is around 8 kilometers away from the beach and local shops. The Fairfield Inn and Suites New Buffalo is located close to the Four Winds Casino, just about 5 kilometers away.
What are the top-rated hotel properties in New Buffalo?
Top-rated properties based on guest reviews include Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo and the New Buffalo Inn & Spa, both known for their customer service and cleanliness.

Essential Hotel Information for New Buffalo

This guide provides essential insights into hotel accommodations in New Buffalo, evaluating 11 properties to help travelers make informed decisions on where and when to stay.

Typical nightly rates range from $100 to $300.

There are 11 hotel properties in New Buffalo.

Peak travel seasons are summer and fall.

Local taxes and fees average 6% on accommodations.

Hotels are about 1.5 km from Lake Michigan and 3 km from the New Buffalo train station.

Other cities in United States

Check-in
06Feb2026Select date
Check-out
07Feb2026Select date
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 Room