The Mermaid & The Alligator, Key West

The Mermaid & The Alligator - An adult-only Key West bed and breakfast with lush gardens, plunge pool, and historic charm

Set in a restored 1904 Queen Anne Victorian mansion, The Mermaid & The Alligator offers nine uniquely decorated guest rooms featuring king or queen beds, private bathrooms, and garden or treetop views. Some accommodations include verandas, soaking tubs, or walk-in showers, with the Treetop Suite accessible via a 40-step staircase. A heated plunge pool surrounded by tropical foliage provides a quiet retreat, while the garden area hosts a daily complimentary breakfast with hot entrees like avocado toast and Belgian waffles. Located on Truman Avenue, the property is a 10-minute walk from Duval Street's shops and restaurants and 5 km from Key West International Airport. The concierge assists with local tours, including the 90-minute Conch Train Tour and Fort Zachary Taylor State Park, known for its beaches and historic fort. While TVs are absent in rooms, a shared living area with Xfinity-TV and board games is available.

Pros

The lush garden setting with tropical plants and migratory birds creates a tranquil, private atmosphere.

Personalized service includes curated local event lists and assistance with tours and activities.

Daily complimentary breakfast features fresh options and rotating hot entrees served poolside.

Adults-only policy ensures a quiet, relaxed environment for couples and solo travelers.

Proximity to Duval Street and major attractions like Hemingway House (0.6 km) and Mallory Square (2.1 km).

Cons

Limited on-site parking with only four regular spaces available on a first-come basis.

Some rooms, like the Treetop Suite, require navigating multiple stairs without elevator access.