Carlisle Inn, Sugarcreek

Carlisle Inn - A countryside retreat with handcrafted decor, Amish dining, and indoor pool

Carlisle Inn offers 69 smoke-free guest rooms, each decorated in one of six woodworking styles and featuring porches or balconies with views of the surrounding countryside. Rooms include handcrafted beds, flat-screen TVs, small refrigerators, and modern amenities like free Wi-Fi. The on-site Dutch Valley Restaurant serves Amish family-style or buffet meals, with options like roast beef, fried chicken, homemade pies, and fresh-baked breads. Guests can relax in fire-lit library spaces or enjoy a swim in the indoor pool with a retractable roof. Meeting facilities accommodate groups from 5 to 300, with AV-equipped rooms and locally sourced refreshments. The hotel sits near landmarks like the World's Largest Cuckoo Clock (3 km) and Alpine Hills Historical Museum (3 km). A continental breakfast is available each morning at Carlisle Inn.

Pros

Rooms feature handcrafted wooden furnishings and private balconies or porches.

The Dutch Valley Restaurant serves traditional Amish dishes, including made-from-scratch pies and roast beef.

An indoor pool with a retractable roof provides year-round swimming.

Meeting spaces support groups up to 300, with flexible seating and locally made refreshments.

The property is within 3 km of attractions like the World's Largest Cuckoo Clock.

Cons

Harry Clever Field, the nearest airport, is 20 km away.